Everton F.C. vs Arsenal F.C. Timeline – Head-to-Head Stats and History

The footballing rivalry between Everton and Arsenal spans more than a century, with the first competitive meeting taking place in 1905. Over the decades, these two historic English clubs have contested approximately 227 to 248 matches across all competitions, establishing one of the most enduring fixtures in the nation’s sporting calendar. While Arsenal holds a decisive advantage in the overall record, Everton has periodically disrupted the North London side’s dominance, particularly during brief resurgent periods at Goodison Park.

Statistical aggregators document varying totals depending on whether cup competitions or league fixtures alone are counted, though all sources confirm Arsenal’s significant historical edge. The Gunners have recorded between 101 and 114 victories compared to Everton’s 65 to 100 wins, with 48 draws separating the sides in a rivalry characterized by contrasting eras of supremacy.

What is the head-to-head record between Everton and Arsenal?

Arsenal dominates the historical ledger, having established an English top-flight record with 104 league victories against Everton alone. Across all competitions, the North London club has accumulated between 101 and 114 wins, while Everton has secured 65 to 100 victories depending on whether wartime matches and minor cup competitions are included.

• Arsenal’s 104 league wins against Everton represent a record for any English club against a single opponent.
• The Gunners average 2.02 goals per game at home versus Everton, totaling 204 goals across 101 home matches.
• Everton holds a slight home advantage historically with 40 wins at Goodison Park compared to Arsenal’s 33 victories there.
• Since 1995, Arsenal has won 41-42 matches to Everton’s 12, with 12 draws.
• In the most recent subset of 51 matches, Arsenal has claimed 31 wins while Everton managed 9.
• Arsenal has scored approximately 348-376 goals in the fixture, significantly outpacing Everton’s 265.
• Everton’s largest victory remains 4-0 from the 1908/09 season, while Arsenal’s 7-0 win in 2005 stands as the fixture’s biggest margin.

Figures from Worldfootball.net and Football.co.uk confirm these records, though databases vary slightly in their inclusion of cup competitions. For comprehensive historical data, see the Arsenal vs Everton head-to-head stats.

What are the recent Everton vs Arsenal match results?

Over the past decade, Arsenal has reasserted dominance after a brief period of Evertonian resistance. Between 2016 and 2025, the Gunners won 14 of 20 Premier League encounters, with Everton securing 4 victories and 2 matches ending level. However, from December 2020 through February 2023, Everton won 4 of 5 meetings, including a rare triumph at the Emirates Stadium in April 2021.

2023-2025 Period

The 2023/24 season saw Arsenal complete a league double over Everton, securing a 1-0 victory at Goodison Park in September 2023 before closing the campaign with a 2-1 win on the final day in May 2024. These results continued a pattern of Arsenal controlling the fixture’s narrative, punctuated only by occasional Everton defensive resilience.

2020-2023 Resurgence

During an anomalous three-year window, Everton reversed historical trends. The sequence included a 2-1 home victory in December 2016, followed by a 1-0 away win at the Emirates in April 2021, and another 1-0 home success in February 2023. This period represented Everton’s most successful stretch against Arsenal since the pre-Premier League era. Complete match listings are available at 11v11.com.

Notable High-Scoring Affairs

Recent seasons have produced several high-margin results favoring Arsenal. In February 2018, the Gunners defeated Everton 5-1 at the Emirates, repeating an identical scoreline from May 2017. The 2021/22 campaign concluded with another 5-1 Arsenal victory in May 2022, while March 2023 saw a 4-0 Arsenal win at the Emirates following Everton’s 1-0 triumph just weeks earlier.

What are the all-time records and biggest wins in Everton vs Arsenal history?

The fixture’s most lopsided results span nearly a century of competition. Arsenal’s 7-0 demolition of Everton on May 11, 2005, at Highbury stands as the largest margin of victory, occurring during the final season at Arsenal’s historic home ground. The Gunners also recorded a 6-1 victory at Everton during the 1958/59 campaign, demonstrating historical dominance on Merseyside.

Everton’s most significant triumph came during the 1908/09 season with a 4-0 victory, a result that remains their largest against Arsenal. The Toffees have also secured multiple 1-0 wins in recent seasons, indicating that while comprehensive victories are rare, narrow defensive performances can yield positive results.

Away form presents a contrasting picture. At Goodison Park, Everton holds a narrow advantage with 40 wins to Arsenal’s 33, with 27 draws. However, since 2016, Arsenal has remained unbeaten in league visits to Everton, reversing decades of Merseyside difficulty. Analysis from SoccerPunter and AiScore confirms Arsenal’s recent superiority in the head-to-head matchup.

What are the key historical moments between Everton and Arsenal?

Beyond the statistical dominance, specific matches have defined this rivalry’s narrative arc. The 1908/09 season established early Everton supremacy with their 4-0 victory, while the post-war era saw Arsenal gradually assert control. The 1958/59 season’s 6-1 Arsenal win at Goodison Park marked a turning point in the fixture’s balance of power.

The modern era features Arsenal’s 2004/05 and 2005/06 campaigns, during which they secured multiple high-margin victories. Conversely, Everton’s brief resurgence between 2020 and 2023, including four wins in five encounters, demonstrated the fixture’s potential for unpredictability despite broader historical trends.

How has the Everton vs Arsenal timeline evolved over time?

1. 1905: First competitive meeting between the clubs.
2. 1908/09: Everton record their largest ever victory over Arsenal, winning 4-0.
3. 1958/59: Arsenal win 6-1 at Everton, establishing away dominance that would characterize future eras.
4. May 11, 2005: Arsenal defeat Everton 7-0 at Highbury, the largest margin in fixture history.
5. December 13, 2016: Everton secure a 2-1 victory, beginning a sporadic but notable run of home successes.
6. April 2021: Everton win 1-0 at the Emirates Stadium, a rare away victory against Arsenal.
7. March 2023: Arsenal respond with a 4-0 home victory, reasserting dominance.
8. May 2024: Arsenal complete the 2023/24 double with a 2-1 victory on the season’s final day.

What is confirmed and what remains unclear about Everton vs Arsenal history?

Current fixture information is available through Flashscore, though as of early 2025, no specific upcoming matches between the clubs are confirmed pending the Premier League’s 2025/26 schedule release.

What is the historical significance of the Everton vs Arsenal fixture?

Both clubs represent foundational elements of English football’s structure. Everton, a founding member of the Football League in 1888, and Arsenal, joining the top flight in 1904, have contested meaningful fixtures across four distinct centuries of competition. Their encounters bridge the sport’s amateur origins through its commercial modernity, with matches at Goodison Park and Highbury (now the Emirates) serving as markers of English football’s architectural and tactical evolution.

The fixture’s significance lies not in traditional rivalry intensity—lacking the geographic proximity of Merseyside or North London derbies—but in historical weight. Arsenal’s record 104 league victories against Everton underscores the Gunners’ sustained excellence, while Everton’s periodic victories demonstrate the competitive balance that has characterized the Premier League era.

What do authoritative sources document about Everton vs Arsenal?

Statistical repositories including Football.co.uk, Sports Mole, and Worldfootball.net aggregate data from official match reports, though methodologies differ regarding cup competition inclusion. Sports Mole confirms Arsenal’s English record of 104 league victories against a single opponent, while Football.co.uk provides granular home-and-away breakdowns demonstrating Arsenal’s Emirates dominance.

“Arsenal has scored around 348-376 goals to Everton’s 265, averaging higher goals per game (e.g., 2.02 at home).”

Aggregated statistical analysis from multiple official databases

The absence of comprehensive individual goalscorer data for the entire historical timeline reflects record-keeping limitations for early 20th-century fixtures, though modern era statistics remain fully documented.

What defines the Everton vs Arsenal head-to-head legacy?

The timeline of Everton versus Arsenal represents a study in sustained dominance punctuated by sporadic resistance. Arsenal’s statistical superiority—manifest in record-breaking league victories, superior goal averages, and recent unbeaten sequences—contrasts with Everton’s historical capacity for significant individual results. For complete historical context, refer to the Arsenal vs Everton head-to-head record and past meetings.

Frequently asked questions